Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Bad Horse's avatar

I thought poetry was dead. I thought Gertrude Stein and her pals had killed it, back when the Platonists were busy killing all the arts—concert music, painting, sculpture, architecture, fiction, dance. I spent years searching the “Year’s Best” collections, /Poetry/ magazine, the little obscure literary journals, and found nothing. And here I find it still alive on substack.

This is part of a much larger pattern. Sometime between 1930 and 2000, the pyramid turned upside-down, one art at a time. The cream began sinking while the shit floated to the top, in everything. The best journalism is on YouTube and substack; the best science journalism is on free blogs. Carnegie Hall performs only the very worst composers from this century; the best work for Hollywood. The last great scientist was slandered for the last 50 years of his life, and again by Scientific American when he died; the only scientist most Americans can name is Neil deGrasse Tyson. The best SF story of the past decade was retracted due to a firestorm of hatred; the most-vile and hateful one was rewarded by a $600,000 MacArthur genius grant. Our tech “visionaries” worship Steve Jobs‘ ghost and scorn Elon Musk. The best colleges are the worst; the best poetry is hiding in pop music. No one reads the stories in The New Yorker anymore; the best fiction will be on the substack of someone with 4 subscribers, or My Little Pony fan-fiction.

Everything that’s still alive is in hiding.

Competence is universally suppressed. I was fired from my last job for working too fast. It took me 4 days this week to contact my health insurance company, trying to get a prescription refilled without which I will die, because their phone tree software doesn’t work. I have a deadly disease, easily fixed with a safe and common operation; but I’ve spent years failing to find a surgeon willing to do the surgery because a famous doctor at Cleveland Clinic has been spreading misinformation about it, flat-out contradicting the entire medical literature in favor of her “lived experience”. Just this week, a revolution in Iran was bloodily suppressed, and neither the news media nor the President has heard about it yet.

It’s a Feast of Fools that never ends.

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?